Rent: The Movie
Walking into the theater, I hoped that it would not be a disaster. The stage version moved me (4 times) and I would hate to see what happened to A Chorus Line when it transferred to film.
It is an imperfect film with many wonderful moments.
Jesse L. Martin is the best thing in the film. His acting, voice and winning smile light up every scene he is in. He make the relationship with Angel seem real and unforced.
Wilson Jermaine Heredia who won the Tony for Angel did fine, although the break-out number Today For You fell a little flat and the costumes did not seem nearly as creative and outrageous as they did on stage.
Rosario Dawson as Mimi made me wish for Daphne Ruben Vega. A capable performance but missing the vulnerability that Daphne brought to the role, the part that makes you care about her. After all, it's not easy to like a heroin junkie, stripper, cheater.
Idena Menzel did her best to look the part of Maureen but was only really successful in the performance piece Over The Moon and in the wonderful duet Take Me Or Leave Me, one of the better numbers in the show. Her acting in non-musical scenes doesn't work for me.
Taye Diggs was surprisingly good as Benny, adding a nice humanity to the villain of Avenue A.
Adam Pascal's songs seemed really trite in screen. He has a nice presence on film otherwise.
And finally, Anthony Rapp. He is so slight in person, but on stage, he makes Mark Cohen a large powerful narrator. On film, he just comes across as a whiney little man with a camera. It's too bad, because his talent is so big.
Anna Deavere Smith, Aaron Lohr and Sarah Silverman had some wasted cameos.
I still feel like this is a wonderful film worth seeing by anyone who likes interesting musical theater with a plot that is more than fluff, even if some of the moments come across as a little saccharine. Particularly when Roger sings life back into Mimi's dead body. Who knew a bad song could resuscitate an Aids victim so quickly.